Top Commercial Leasing Mistakes to Avoid

November 21, 2026 | David Beshay

A commercial lease can look manageable until the first rent review, repair bill or relocation decision lands on your desk. The top commercial leasing mistakes are rarely about choosing the wrong premises alone. They happen when a business owner treats the lease as a standard formality instead of a long-term financial commitment.

The right site can support growth, staff retention and customer access. The wrong lease can consume working capital and limit your options for years. No guesswork. No assumptions. Before signing, understand what you are agreeing to, what it will cost in practice and how easily you can adapt if the business changes.

Own commercial premises in Mandurah or the Peel region? See Beshay Realty’s commercial leasing service or request a property-specific leasing discussion. We can discuss presentation and finding suitable tenants; a qualified legal adviser should review lease obligations.

Top commercial leasing mistakes that cost businesses

Focusing on base rent and ignoring the true occupancy cost

A lower advertised rent does not automatically mean a better deal. Commercial tenants need to look beyond the headline figure and calculate the full cost of occupying the premises.

Depending on the lease and applicable law, these costs can include permitted outgoings, council rates, strata levies, land tax where recoverable, building insurance, utilities, cleaning, security and GST. Not every charge can lawfully be passed on: in Western Australia, special rules apply to retail shop leases. An industrial warehouse, office suite and retail tenancy can each carry very different expense profiles, even when the weekly rent appears similar.

Ask for a clear outgoings estimate and understand whether it is fixed, capped or subject to reconciliation. If the landlord estimates annual outgoings at one figure but the actual costs rise substantially, you need to know who carries that increase. A lease that looks affordable in year one can become a pressure point by year three.

Work from an all-in occupancy budget, not rent alone. Include the cost of the fitout, signage, internet, parking, insurance, legal advice and moving. That is the number your business must comfortably carry.

Signing a term that does not suit the business plan

Lease length is a trade-off. A longer term can provide security and may give you greater leverage to negotiate rent-free periods, fitout contributions or favourable review terms. It can also lock you into a location that no longer works.

A short term offers flexibility, but it may leave you exposed when the landlord wants the space back, proposes a higher rent or declines to renew just as the business gains momentum. There is no universally correct answer. It depends on your business model, your capital investment in the site and how difficult it would be to relocate.

Before agreeing to a term, consider where the business needs to be in two, three and five years. If the premises requires a substantial fitout or specialised equipment, a brief lease may be poor value. If the business is testing a new market or relies on changing customer patterns, flexibility may matter more.

Options to renew can be valuable, but only if the wording is clear. Check when the option must be exercised, whether rent is set by market review or a stated formula, and what happens if you miss the notice deadline. A good option is not useful if it is easy to lose through an administrative error.

Accepting vague rent review clauses

Rent reviews deserve close attention because their impact compounds. A fixed annual increase is predictable. CPI-linked increases may appear reasonable, but inflation can move sharply. Market reviews can reflect local demand, but they can also create uncertainty.

The problem is not simply the method. It is the detail. Is there a minimum increase? Can the rent go down at a market review, or is there a ratchet clause preventing it? Does the review occur every year, at an option date or both? Are incentives considered when market rent is assessed?

Small wording differences can change the long-term cost materially. Do not accept a review mechanism because it is described as standard. Standard for whom? The lease should be commercially workable for both parties, not merely familiar to the landlord or their agent.

Overlooking make-good and repair obligations

One of the most expensive surprises in commercial leasing arrives at the end of the term. A make-good clause can require a tenant to remove partitions, fixtures, signage, cabling, flooring and improvements, then return the premises to a specified condition.

That obligation can be reasonable. The issue is signing broad wording without knowing what existed when you moved in or what the landlord expects on exit. A tenant may spend heavily on a fitout that improves the space, then be required to remove it at their own cost.

Get a detailed condition report with photographs before possession. Record existing damage, services, ceilings, floors, paintwork, doors and external areas where relevant. Clarify repair responsibilities for air conditioning, roller doors, plumbing, electrical systems and fire services. Wear and tear, structural repairs and maintenance are not interchangeable concepts.

Where possible, negotiate the make-good requirement at the start, not in the final month of the lease. Agreeing that selected improvements can remain, or setting out a defined scope of works, can prevent a costly dispute later.

Assuming the permitted use covers future plans

The permitted use clause determines what the premises can legally be used for under the lease. It should match the business you operate now, but it should also allow reasonable growth.

A narrow use may stop you from adding a product line, providing a related service, subleasing part of the premises or changing the operating model. For retail businesses, it can also interact with centre rules, exclusivity arrangements and trading-hour requirements.

Check planning approvals, zoning, parking requirements, health regulations and building compliance separately. A landlord agreeing to lease a property does not guarantee that your intended use is approved. If approval is critical, make the lease conditional on receiving it or ensure there is a clear exit if it cannot be obtained.

Mandurah example — 115 Mandurah Terrace: Beshay Realty currently advertises this former restaurant for sale or lease, highlighting its commercial kitchen and parking. The marketing describes alternative uses or redevelopment as subject to approval. For a prospective occupier, an existing fitout and advertised planning context do not automatically approve a different operation. Check the proposed use, relevant City of Mandurah approvals, building requirements and fitout conditions with the appropriate authorities and advisers before committing. This is an advertised opportunity, not an example of a completed lease or an approved new use.

Treating incentives as free money

Rent-free periods, fitout contributions and reduced starting rents can make a lease more attractive. They are useful commercial tools, but they are not free money. Incentives may be reflected in a higher face rent, a longer commitment or repayment obligations if the tenant defaults or leaves early.

Read the incentive deed and lease together. Understand when the incentive is paid, whether it is paid in cash or credited against rent, and whether it must be repaid in whole or in part if circumstances change. A generous contribution tied to an unsuitable term can still be a poor deal.

The strongest negotiation is not always the largest incentive. Sometimes a lower annual increase, clearer make-good terms or a better option to renew is worth more over the life of the lease.

Failing to protect an exit route

Business conditions change. A tenant may need to sell the business, downsize, expand, merge or move closer to customers. Without sensible assignment, subletting or early termination provisions, the lease can become an obstacle.

Check whether you can assign the lease to a buyer of the business and what landlord consent is required. For WA retail shop leases covered by the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act, an assignment is subject to specific protections about reasonable grounds for refusing consent. Different terms may apply to other commercial premises. Also ask whether you remain liable after an assignment and whether a bank guarantee or personal guarantee can be reduced or released over time.

Personal guarantees need particular care. They can expose directors or business owners personally if the company cannot meet its obligations. This is not a clause to skim because the business is trading well today.

Western Australian retail leasing rules are different

Before accepting a retail shop lease in Mandurah or elsewhere in WA, check whether the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 applies. Covered leases have statutory disclosure and rent-review protections that do not automatically apply to every office, warehouse or industrial lease. For example, the landlord generally must give the prescribed disclosure statement at least seven days before the retail lease is entered into; management fees cannot be recovered from the retail tenant as operating expenses; and a market-rent review cannot use a ratchet clause that prevents rent from falling. The correct treatment of land tax and other outgoings also depends on the applicable provisions.

These differences matter to tenants and owners alike. Review the WA Consumer Protection commercial tenancy guidance and obtain independent legal advice on your particular premises and lease before agreeing to costs or clauses.

A better way to approach a commercial lease

Start with a written brief before inspecting properties. Set a maximum all-in occupancy cost, preferred term, required floor area, access needs, parking, power, loading, visibility and non-negotiable operational requirements. This prevents a good-looking premises from pulling the business into a bad commitment.

Once you identify a suitable site, negotiate the commercial terms before accepting that the lease wording is settled. Rent, reviews, options, incentives, outgoings, fitout rights, permitted use and make-good should be considered as one package. Winning on rent while accepting an open-ended make-good obligation is not a clean win.

For Mandurah businesses, local trading patterns, access routes and surrounding development can matter as much as the building itself. A site that suits a professional office may be wrong for a trade supplier, hospitality venue or customer-facing retailer. Assess how the location works at the hours your business actually operates.

Finally, have the lease reviewed by a qualified legal adviser before signing. Commercial property representation can help you secure and negotiate the right premises, but legal advice is what confirms the obligations in the document. The cost of reviewing a lease is modest compared with being tied to the wrong terms.

A commercial lease should give your business room to perform, not force it to work around avoidable restrictions. Ask direct questions early, negotiate the terms that will matter later and only sign when the numbers and obligations are clear.

Commercial owners: avoid problems before finding a tenant

If you own a commercial property in Mandurah or the wider Peel region, the same mistakes can undermine your leasing campaign. Before advertising, clarify the permitted use, confirm which outgoings are actually recoverable, document the property’s condition and obtain advice on the proposed lease terms. An attractive headline rent is only useful when the occupancy costs and obligations are clear to a suitable tenant.

For property-specific leasing advice, explore Beshay Realty’s Mandurah commercial leasing service or send a commercial property-owner enquiry. The enquiry form lets owners specify whether they are considering a sale, a lease or both. Beshay Realty can discuss marketing and tenant suitability; seek independent legal advice for your lease documentation.

David Beshay

David Beshay is the Licensee and Principal of Beshay Realty. With a background in civil engineering and property investment, he shares practical insights on selling, leasing and property management across Perth, Mandurah and surrounding areas.