Commercial Lease Review: What to Check First

November 1, 2026 | David Beshay

A commercial premises can look right, feel right and still become an expensive problem on paper. The rent is only one number. A proper commercial lease review tests the full commitment: what you will pay, what you must maintain, how you can leave, and what happens if the business changes direction.

For landlords, the same process protects income and the condition of the asset. For tenants, it prevents a promising site from becoming a liability. No guesswork. No assumptions based on a quick conversation or an agent’s summary. The written terms matter, but applicable legislation and statutory rights may qualify or override them.

For Mandurah and Peel commercial property owners

Before offering a tenancy, consider the proposed use, the condition of the premises, any incentives and the work needed to make the space suitable. Compare the heads of agreement with the approvals held for the premises: an existing fit-out does not, by itself, establish that a different business use is approved. A documented condition report and clear responsibility for maintenance can help prevent disputes after handover.

For the landlord-specific clauses to discuss with your solicitor, read our guide to key commercial lease clauses for landlords. If you are considering leasing, selling or repositioning commercial premises in Mandurah or Peel, send a commercial-owner enquiry to Beshay Realty about marketing and negotiation. Obtain independent legal advice on final lease terms and statutory obligations.

Start with the deal, not just the rent

Before reading clauses line by line, confirm that the lease reflects the commercial agreement you believe you have made. Compare the lease against the heads of agreement, offer to lease, emails and incentive proposal. Small differences can have major consequences once the term begins.

Check the premises description carefully. Does it include the whole area you inspected, allocated car bays, storage, signage rights, loading access or exclusive-use areas? If a plan is attached, make sure it is accurate. A tenant who assumes use of a rear storeroom or shared parking area without it being documented may have very little leverage later.

The permitted use deserves the same attention. It should be broad enough for the business you operate now and practical growth you can reasonably foresee. A narrow use clause can stop a tenant adding a complementary service, changing a product mix or assigning the lease to a suitable buyer. Landlords, on the other hand, need a permitted use that protects the property, neighbouring occupiers and planning compliance without being unnecessarily restrictive.

Commercial lease review: the financial commitments

Headline rent gets attention because it is easy to compare. The real cost of occupation is broader. Your review should establish the total likely annual commitment, how it changes, and which figures are fixed versus estimated.

Rent reviews and market reviews

Identify when rent is reviewed and how the increase is calculated. Common methods include fixed percentage increases, CPI increases, market rent reviews and combinations of these across a term and option periods. There is no universally better structure. A fixed increase offers certainty, while CPI may track economic conditions. Market rent can be fairer at renewal, but it introduces uncertainty and often a valuation process if the parties disagree.

Read the market review mechanism, not merely the words “market rent”. Check who appoints the valuer, what assumptions apply, whether the rent can decrease, and what occurs if a determination is delayed. A poorly drafted process can produce an avoidable dispute at exactly the point a tenant is deciding whether to stay.

Outgoings, GST and hidden operating costs

Outgoings can change the real cost of occupying a commercial property. The lease should identify each expense the tenant may lawfully pay, how it is calculated and apportioned, and when it is due. Depending on the premises, the agreement and applicable law, recoverable items may include council rates, water charges, eligible strata levies, building insurance, common-area cleaning, security and maintenance. Land tax and other owner charges require separate legal checks; do not assume every item in a landlord’s budget can be passed on.

WA retail shop lease warning: Where the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 applies, section 12(1f) prevents a landlord recovering management fees from a retail shop tenant, even if the lease purports to require payment. Section 12 also regulates the specification, calculation, apportionment and disclosure of operating expenses. Different rules may apply outside the Act. Refer to WA Consumer Protection’s commercial tenancy guidance and the current WA legislation, and obtain lease-specific legal advice before agreeing to an outgoings schedule.

Ask for recent outgoings statements and budgets, then compare them with the proposed estimate. If the building has ageing services, upcoming strata works or high maintenance needs, an attractive base rent may not remain attractive for long. Tenants should also clarify GST treatment, payment timing and whether any administration fee applies.

For a detailed breakdown of possible recoverable costs and the retail shop restrictions, see our WA commercial outgoings guide. This commercial lease review focuses on how the expenses fit with rent, maintenance, options and exit obligations before signing.

For landlords, clarity is protection. Vague outgoings wording creates friction, delayed payments and challenges to recovery. A transparent schedule supports a stronger leasing relationship from day one.

Incentives are not free money

Rent-free periods, fit-out contributions and cash incentives can make a deal competitive. They can also contain repayment triggers. Review when the incentive is paid, whether it is inclusive of GST, and whether some or all of it must be repaid if the tenant defaults, assigns the lease or ends it early.

A generous incentive attached to an unmanageable make-good obligation is not necessarily a good deal. Look at the entire term, not the opening months.

Understand repairs, maintenance and make-good

This is one of the highest-risk sections in a commercial lease. The practical question is simple: when something fails, who pays? The legal answer can be far less simple.

Separate structural elements, essential services, plant and equipment, internal repairs, glass, air-conditioning, plumbing, fire compliance and common areas. A tenant should not assume that a landlord is responsible simply because they own the building. Equally, a landlord should not rely on broad wording that is likely to be contested when major work is required.

Make-good is the other pressure point. At the end of the lease, must the tenant remove fit-out, reinstate walls, repair damage, strip signage, repaint, replace flooring or return the premises to a bare shell? The answer should be specific. Photographs and a condition report at handover can save both parties a costly argument years later.

If the tenant is investing heavily in a specialised fit-out, negotiate make-good before signing. Do not wait until the business is ready to move out and the bond is at risk.

Protect flexibility when circumstances change

Businesses change. Owners sell. Partners leave. Markets soften. A lease should deal with these realities rather than pretend they will not occur.

Review assignment and subletting rights. A tenant may need to sell the business or bring in another operator before the term expires. Check the landlord’s consent process, the information required, whether consent can be withheld, and whether the outgoing tenant or guarantor remains liable after an assignment.

Also consider the renewal options. An option is valuable only if it is validly exercised. Confirm the notice window, method of notice, conditions that could prevent exercise and how rent is set for the further term. Missing an option deadline by a few days can put a successful business in a weak negotiating position.

For landlords, options should provide a reliable framework without preventing a sensible repositioning or sale strategy. The right balance depends on the property, tenant covenant and likely future demand.

Check security, guarantees and default provisions

Security can take the form of a cash bond, bank guarantee or personal guarantee. Tenants should understand the amount, the circumstances in which it can be called upon, and when it must be returned. Directors should be especially careful with personal guarantees. They can create personal exposure well beyond the company’s immediate cash position.

Default clauses should be read when everyone is still on good terms. Look at notice periods, interest on overdue amounts, legal costs, termination rights and the landlord’s remedies. A fair lease gives clear notice and a workable opportunity to fix a breach. It should not leave either side guessing about the consequences of missed rent, unauthorised alterations or failure to insure.

Do not overlook approvals, compliance and insurance

The premises may suit the business commercially but still require approvals before trading can begin. Check planning, building, health, liquor, signage and fire safety requirements relevant to the proposed use. Confirm who is responsible for obtaining approvals, paying fees and carrying out required works.

Insurance provisions need the same discipline. The lease should specify the landlord’s building cover, the tenant’s public liability and contents obligations, required policy limits, and any need to note another party’s interest. If the premises become unusable after damage, the lease should also address rent abatement, repair obligations and termination rights.

Western Australian retail shop leases and approval checks

Not all commercial tenancies are governed by the same rules. If a proposed lease falls within Western Australia’s Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985, statutory protections may apply to disclosure, rent reviews and other terms. For a covered retail shop lease, a landlord is generally required to give the prescribed disclosure statement at least seven days before the lease is entered into. Check the applicable documents, including the tenant guide, and whether any exemptions or special circumstances apply. An office, warehouse or other business tenancy should not automatically be treated as a covered retail shop lease. See WA Consumer Protection’s commercial tenancy guidance, and ask a WA commercial-leasing solicitor to confirm the legal position for the specific premises.

Permitted use in the lease does not, by itself, establish that the proposed business may lawfully operate at the site. Before committing to fit-out or opening costs, ask the relevant local government whether development approval, a building permit, an occupancy or classification change, health approvals or industry licences are needed. The answer depends on the existing approvals and intended activity. See the WA Government’s building approvals guidance. Agree in writing who obtains and pays for required approvals and what happens if they are refused or delayed.

Use the right people before you sign

A commercial agent can help assess the market position of the rent, incentive, term and property. An accountant can test the cash-flow impact. A solicitor should review the legal documents and explain the risk in plain English. Each role matters because a commercial lease is not just a property document. It is an operating cost, a legal commitment and, often, a key part of the value of the business.

At Beshay Realty, the focus is on clear commercial terms and disciplined representation, so clients can negotiate with a full view of what they are taking on. The right premises should support the next move, not limit it.

Considering a shop, office or other commercial tenancy in Mandurah or the Peel region? Explore Beshay Realty’s commercial leasing service and contact the team about the property, market terms and your requirements. Obtain independent legal advice on lease wording and statutory obligations before signing.

A lease is easiest to negotiate before it is signed. Ask the hard questions while there is still room to change the answer.

David Beshay

David Beshay is the Licensee and Principal of Beshay Realty. With a background in civil engineering and property investment, he shares practical insights on selling, leasing and property management across Perth, Mandurah and surrounding areas.