Can Landlords Refuse Tenant Pets in WA Rentals?

November 3, 2026 | David Beshay

A tenant sends through a pet request. Your first instinct may be to say no and protect the property. But can landlords refuse tenant pets in Western Australia? Sometimes, yes. A blanket refusal is no longer the simple, low-risk option it once appeared to be.

For landlords, the issue is not whether pets can cause damage. They can. The real question is whether the concern is reasonable, supported by the property and handled through the correct process. Good leasing decisions protect the asset without creating an unnecessary dispute or narrowing your tenant pool.

Own a rental in Mandurah or Peel? If you are comparing how agencies handle tenant requests and future leasing, request a property-specific rental appraisal from Beshay Realty. If you have already received Form 25, an appraisal enquiry does not replace your written response or any required Commissioner application within the statutory timeframe.

Can landlords refuse tenant pets in WA?

Western Australian rental laws require landlords to consider pet requests properly. A tenant generally needs written consent before keeping a pet at the property. However, a landlord cannot simply refuse because they prefer a no-pets tenancy.

Refusal is limited to specific grounds, and the process matters. A landlord may refuse without Commissioner approval where keeping the pet would breach a law or an applicable strata by-law. Other reasons for refusal generally require an application to the Commissioner for Consumer Protection, made within the required timeframe. A general preference for a pet-free rental is not enough. See WA Consumer Protection’s renting-with-pets guidance.

This is a material shift for property owners. “No pets” in an old advert or a personal concern about carpet damage is not, by itself, a complete strategy. The property, the proposed animal, applicable strata requirements and the tenancy agreement all need to be considered.

The safest approach is simple: respond in writing, on time, and based on the facts of that particular request. No guesswork. No emotional decisions.

The pet request process landlords need to understand

On receiving Form 25, use this practical checklist: date-stamp the request; review the particular property, tenancy terms and any relevant strata rules; assess the proposed pet and lawful conditions; respond in writing within 14 days starting the next day; and apply to the Commissioner within the same period if the proposed refusal or conditions require approval. Keep copies of the request, response, evidence and any application. Refer to WA Consumer Protection’s current guidance for the legal requirements.

During a tenancy, the tenant must use Form 25 (Pet Request Form) to request permission, give it to the landlord and keep a copy. Where a pet is agreed at the start of the tenancy, its details and lawful conditions should be recorded in the tenancy agreement. A completed Form 25 gives the owner or property manager the information needed to assess the particular animal and property.

The landlord has 14 days, counting from the day after receiving Form 25, to respond to the tenant in writing. If a proposed refusal or special condition needs Commissioner approval, the landlord must also apply to the Commissioner within that 14-day period. If the required response or application is missed, the request can be automatically approved, without conditions that required Commissioner approval. Record the date received, the written response and any application. Consumer Protection explains the timing and approval process.

Landlords can approve a pet request with certain lawful conditions. Limits on the number of pets and conditions concerning cleaning, maintenance or fumigation can be imposed without Commissioner approval. Other proposed conditions, such as requiring the pet to remain outside, generally need Commissioner approval before they apply. Keep every condition clear, specific and consistent with current law.

When Commissioner approval is needed

A landlord who wants to refuse because a home is unsuitable, there are too many animals, pet damage may exceed the bond, there is a significant health or safety risk, or keeping the pet would cause undue hardship generally needs the Commissioner to determine the request. Do not treat these examples as automatic permission to refuse: the facts and supporting evidence matter. Check the current official grounds and conditions before responding.

For a standard WA residential tenancy, the maximum pet bond is $350 in total, regardless of the number of pets. It may be used for fumigation or pet-related damage and must be lodged with Bonds Administration. An existing pet bond can only be increased at the next rent increase or when an additional pet request is approved. No pet bond applies to an assistance animal. See Consumer Protection’s pet bond and bond variation guidance. Tenants remain responsible for damage beyond fair wear and tear.

If you believe refusal is justified, get clear advice promptly. The correct pathway may involve an application to the Commissioner rather than simply sending a one-line rejection to the tenant.

When refusal may be reasonable

Every application turns on its facts. A large dog in a small upstairs apartment with no suitable outdoor area raises different issues from a cat in a secure villa. Likewise, a property governed by a valid strata scheme rule or affected by a legal restriction must be assessed differently from a standalone house.

The strongest grounds are specific and evidence-based. Think about the nature of the animal, the design and condition of the premises, access arrangements, safety concerns, and any enforceable restrictions that apply to the property.

A landlord may have a stronger case where the proposed pet is genuinely unsuitable for the dwelling or where keeping it would breach a binding rule. But assumptions are weak ground. Size alone is not always decisive. Breed stereotypes are not a substitute for evidence. And concern about possible damage is not the same as proof that damage is likely or unmanageable.

Assistance animals are not treated as ordinary pets under these tenancy rules. An eligible assistance animal does not require a landlord’s pet consent, and the landlord cannot charge a pet bond for it. The animal must meet the applicable legal criteria. Where its status is unclear, seek appropriate advice rather than applying a routine pet restriction or assuming that every animal described as an assistance animal qualifies.

For strata properties, check the current by-laws and obtain the relevant documents before responding. Do not rely on what a previous owner, neighbour or strata manager says the rules “usually” are. The wording matters, as does whether the by-law is enforceable in the circumstances.

A pet-friendly tenancy does not mean an unprotected investment

Some landlords hear the rule changes and assume they have lost control of their property. That is not the position. A well-managed tenancy still gives the owner practical tools to manage risk.

The tenancy agreement should clearly record approved pets and any lawful conditions. Your entry and exit property condition reports need to be detailed, dated and supported by quality photographs. This is not paperwork for paperwork’s sake. If a dispute arises over scratched flooring, damaged flyscreens or odour treatment, the evidence will matter.

Routine inspections should also be purposeful. Look for early signs of damage, verify that the property is being maintained properly, and address issues before they become expensive. A vague inspection report helps no one. A specific report, communicated promptly, gives both the tenant and landlord a fair opportunity to act.

At the end of the tenancy, distinguish pet-related damage from fair wear and tear. Worn carpet in a long-term tenancy is not automatically pet damage. But urine staining, chewed joinery, damaged blinds or excessive cleaning needs may be recoverable where the evidence supports the claim.

Insurance also deserves a closer look. Policies differ on pet-related damage, tenant damage and exclusions. Check the product disclosure statement before relying on cover that may not apply. Insurance is a backstop, not a substitute for strong tenant selection and regular property management.

Why a considered yes can be commercially smart

There is a practical leasing case for considering pets fairly. Many reliable tenants own pets, and a well-presented pet-friendly home can attract more enquiry. In parts of Mandurah and across WA, landlords who rule out every pet owner may be shrinking their applicant pool without achieving meaningful extra protection.

That does not mean every request should be approved. It means the decision should be commercial, not reflexive. A good tenant with a well-documented pet request may represent less risk than a poorly screened applicant with no animals.

The key is to assess the entire application. Review rental history, income, references, household size, the animal’s details and the suitability of the premises. If the tenant is otherwise strong, a pet request should be one factor in the decision, not a reason to stop the assessment.

A property that is hard to re-let, over-priced or poorly maintained will not become a better investment simply because it has a strict no-pets position. Leasing well requires the same discipline as selling well: understand the market, protect your position and make decisions that serve the result.

Common mistakes landlords should avoid

The first mistake is relying on an outdated standard lease or advertisement that says pets are prohibited. Templates and listing language need to reflect current law and the property’s actual circumstances.

The second is delaying the response. Pet requests have timeframes. If you need strata documents, legal guidance or more information, act immediately rather than waiting until the deadline is close.

The third is creating unreasonable conditions. A condition should address a real risk and be capable of being followed. Vague demands such as requiring “professional cleaning at all times” are unlikely to give either party clarity.

The fourth is failing to document the decision. Whether you consent, set conditions or seek to refuse, keep a clear record of the request, your response, relevant reports and any supporting material. When pressure rises, good records create control.

Finally, do not confuse a pet approval with permission for every animal. Consent should identify what has been approved. If the tenant later introduces additional pets, deal with that through the tenancy process rather than letting the situation drift.

Make the decision with evidence, not instinct

Pet requests are now part of modern property management in WA. Landlords still have rights, but they must be exercised carefully and within the process. The right answer may be yes, no, or yes with reasonable conditions. It depends on the property and the facts.

Before responding, check the tenancy documents, inspect any relevant strata rules, assess the animal against the premises and make sure your records are ready. Use Form 25, respond within 14 days and apply for a Commissioner decision where required. A clear, timely decision protects your investment far better than an automatic refusal ever will.

Managing a Mandurah or Peel rental property?

Pet requests are one part of managing a rental well. Accurate records, careful inspections, lawful conditions and prompt communication matter just as much. If you own a rental in Mandurah or surrounding Peel suburbs, explore Beshay Realty’s Mandurah property management and rental appraisal service to discuss your property and its leasing requirements. The linked service page includes a rental appraisal enquiry form. This article is general information; for a dispute or a time-sensitive Commissioner application, use the official Consumer Protection guidance above or seek independent legal advice.

David Beshay

David Beshay is the Licensee and Principal of Beshay Realty. With a background in civil engineering and property investment, he shares practical insights on selling, leasing and property management across Perth, Mandurah and surrounding areas.